image1 image1 image1

My girlfriend and I went to Eddie’s Hot Dog Stand for a treat before we went to the dance hall. I ordered a hot dog with onions, and the good looking “guy” next me said ‘Phew!’ I said, ‘I don’t care, Eddie’s sandwiches are the best there is!” and I glared back. Later I saw him at the dance hall. He asked me to dance several times. I found out his name was Arthur A. Knight of Rome. Just as I was about to go home, he asked me if he could buy me a sandwich at Eddie’s—onions and all! Of course, I said yes. That’s the way it all started, and continued for the next few years until June 25, 1941, when we were married.

Marie A. Knight


  1. I've been visiting Eddie's since I was a child and now that I have my own daughter, she loves it just as much as I do! Hope to keep coming back for many more years!

    from / 2011-10-21 08:10

  2. We stayed in Sylvan Beach last year My family are from Canastota NY, I now live in Plattsburgh NY, We always go to Eddies Restaurant it's the best place to eat and everyone is very friendly, good prices too. we will be back in Aug. thank for being the best. Mrs Smallarz

    from / 2011-07-19 00:07

  3. Every summer in the mid-1950's, our family (including our grandparents, aunts, uncles & cousins) vacationed at Sylvan Beach. One of the most vivid memories is that of Eddie's! Unforgetable memories of hot fudge sundaes and that sugar-grained fudge bring a smile to my face. Thanks for the memories.

    from / 2011-07-15 13:07

  4. my husband and i love eating at eddies, best place in town....

    from / 2011-06-24 14:06

  5. I have been coming to Eddie's and enjoying thier food for as long as I can remember. My mother Jackie Cordell started the tradition in our family many years ago. My mother as since past but the tradition still lives on in our family. I have many fond memories of sitting in a booth listening to songs by Journey and being served by our favorite waitresses Genie and Sandi. If my mother was here today I know she would be calling me saying,"let's go to Eddie's, I am dying for an antipasta, rolls w butter, hot covered meatball sandwich and hot pepers". That sounds so good right now to me I think I am gonna have to take the drive today with my kids and enjoy once again your delicious food. Thank you so much for continuing to serve your great food without any changes year after year. Holly Cordell

    from / 2011-06-12 12:06